South Bend Mayor James Mueller presents a key to the city to Sunny Italy Cafe Thursday

NOW: South Bend Mayor James Mueller presents a key to the city to Sunny Italy Cafe Thursday

SOUTH BEND, Ind. -- South Bend Mayor James Mueller presented a key to the city to Sunny Italy Cafe on Thursday evening, Nov. 19, during a surprise celebration of the restaurant's 100th anniversary. Mueller called the key the highest honor he is able to give a person or organization.

Family, friends and longtime customers packed the restaurant's lobby, which was decorated with "100" balloons and poster boards tracing the restaurant's history.

Gene Bamber, a relative of the owner, organized the surprise; guests gathered outside and came in together. Owner and manager Sis Elliot said she and her three brothers grew up in the apartment upstairs, and said the honor was extremely special to her and her family.

"We lived upstairs in this building. We walked downtown, we took a cab downtown. We ate downtown. We shop downtown, and we went to the movie theaters downtown, so to get something so special from South Bend is extremely special to me and to my family."

She recalled the late Rev. Theodore Hesburgh telling her his first purchase at the restaurant was a five-cent ice cream, all the money he had. Mueller said local restaurants create the culture and character of a city.

"I think the best thing about Sunny Italy is the people I have met here. Some of my best friends, they're right here, were customers… My favorite story, Father Hesburgh was here. He had his special table, which is right next to the three steps. He stopped me, and he said… What do you think I ate?… He said, I had ice cream. It was five cents, and it was all the money I had."

Mueller acknowledged the exact anniversary date may be in question. The restaurant opened in 1926 as the North Niles Avenue Cafe; Jimmy and Josie Bamber bought it in 1940 and renamed it Sunny Italy Cafe.

"I grew up coming to Sunny Italy, so I started out very simple, spaghetti, you know, spaghetti and meatballs… Everybody alive in South Bend knows about Sunny Italy, because it's been here for pretty much everybody's lifetime. And that kind of stability and predictability of knowing you can get a good Italian meal right here on Niles Avenue, is something that creates a city."

Close