Michiana candy makers work to keep holiday chocolate traditions alive despite high cocoa costs
SOUTH BEND, Ind. — Raw cocoa bean prices surged to $12,000 a metric ton in 2024 and 2025 before dropping to around $3,700 this year, though costs remain well above pre-pandemic levels of $2,000 to $2,500, according to International Monetary Fund data.
Local candy makers in Michiana are feeling that financial squeeze, too. Because chocolate is a longtime holiday staple in the region, businesses are working to keep seasonal traditions alive despite higher expenses.
Claeys Candy, a family-run business dating back to 1919 when its first candy sold for 5 cents, is gearing up for the holiday rush with its signature Chocolate Charlie, a popular chocolate fudge combination. Company President Gregg Claeys, a third-generation owner, said preparation for the seasonal favorite begins months in advance.
"We start preparing for it way back in September and getting in all the raw materials, the chocolate, number one Spanish peanuts, coconut," Claeys said. "So that's been all the packaging, the boxes, and so that's all done earlier, and then the actual production starts about the middle of October and runs to about the second week of December."
The company has faced price increases not only in chocolate, but also in freight, importing and petroleum-based products, driving up the overall cost of operating a candy business. Vice President Brian Machalleck said last year brought the steepest chocolate price hike he has ever seen, though it has not slowed down production of the Michiana staple.
"It's great. I mean, we've been here for 106 years now, so it's just great," Machalleck said.
The South Bend Chocolate Cafe is also navigating higher costs. Five years ago, the shop's in-house chocolates increased from $26.99 to $35.99 a pound.
The downtown shop also carries holiday Chocolate Charlies, which sold for $12.99 for a small box and $22.99 for a large box in 2023 before prices adjusted again this season.
"We're gonna do the small boxes at $14.99 and the big boxes for $24.99," said Duana Bivens, store manager at South Bend Chocolates.
Even as prices climb, local candy makers and customers continue to prioritize the century-old tradition.
"It's definitely a tradition because we hear that all the time from the consumers that it's not Christmas without Chocolate Charlie," Claeys said.
For Bivens, the holiday treat is personal.
"It was a part of our Christmas every year, as far as I can remember," Bivens said. "My brothers, they all three get Chocolate Charlie for Christmas."
Staff at South Bend Chocolates advise shoppers to stop in early, noting that customers typically buy multiple boxes at a time and the shop expects its supply of Chocolate Charlies to sell out within a couple of days.